RSS Feed

Tag Archives: satyam computers

Indian Supreme Court to Reconsider Bhatia International

In this post, SUMIT RAI reports on the recent reference to a five-member bench of the Indian Supreme Court to reconsider the ratio in Bhatia International and Satyam Computers; skeptically adding that a solution to the impasse may not be reached anytime soon.

A three-member bench of the Indian Supreme Court, chaired by the Chief Justice, has referred the Bhatia International ratio for reconsideration to a five-member constitutional bench on 1st November 2011. The Supreme Court has also invited anyone interested in being heard on the issue to file an intervention. The matter is to be placed before the five-member bench on 10th January 2012.

The reference was made in the case of Bharat Aluminium Co. v. Kaiser Aluminium Technical Services Inc. In early 2008, Justice Katju (now retired) while sitting in a division bench had expressed his reservation on the correctness of the Bhatia ratio and the apex court’s decision in Satyam Computers following that ratio. He had particularly expressed doubts over the interpretation given to section 2(2) of the Indian Arbitration Act (1996). Following this, the case was placed before a three-member bench, which has now referred it to a five-member bench. Read the rest of this entry

Advertisements